Communicating Your Report to the Editor

Once you have completed your evaluation of the article the next step is to write up your report. As a courtesy, let the Editor know if it looks like you might miss your deadline. Some journals may request that you complete a form, checking various aspects of the paper, others will request an overview of your remarks. Either way, it is helpful to provide a quick summary of the article at the beginning of your report. This serves the dual purpose of reminding the Editor of the details of the report and also reassuring the Author(s) and Editor that you have understood the article. The report should contain the key elements of your review, addressing the points outlined in the preceding section. Commentary should be courteous and constructive, and should not include any personal remarks or personal details including your name. Providing insight into any deficiencies is important. You should explain and support your judgment so that both the Editor and Author(s) are able to fully understand the reasoning behind your comments. You should indicate whether your comments are your own opinion or are reflected by the data.

When you make a recommendation regarding an article, it is worth considering the categories the Editor most likely uses for classifying the article.

a)  Reject (explain the reason in the report)
b) Accept (without revision)
c) Revise (either major or minor)
d) Resubmit after Major Revision

 

Reviewer Name	Reviewer Family	Affiliation	Publons/WoS ID
Mahdi	Abadi	Tarbiat Modares University	AAP-8397-2021
Farzaneh	Abazari	Iran University of Science and Technology	W-5917-2019
Ali Azam	Abbasfar	Tehran University
Abdolali	Abdipour	Amirkabir University of Technology
Mohammad	Abdollahiazgomi	Iran University of Science and Technology	D-3734-2009
Mohammad Javad	Abdollahi-fard	Tafresh University	AAC-3767-2022
Ahmad	Abdollahzadeh	Amirkabir University of Technology
Kambiz	Abedi	Shahid Beheshti University	AAB-7264-2022
Hamidreza	Abutalebi	Yazd University	G-6823-2015
Sepideh	Adabi	Tehran North Branch	AAF-1731-2020
Emad	Aghayi	George Mason Univesity, U.S.	L-8198-2019
Mohammad	Ahadi	Amirkabir University of Technology	ACN-9068-2022
Ali	Ahmadi	K. N. Toosi University of Technology	AAK-7037-2020
Mohammadreza	Ahmadi	ICT Research Institute	AET-8326-2022
Arash	Ahmadi	Carleton University, Canada	GQA-5541-2022
Mahmoud	Ahmadianattari	K. N. Toosi University of Technology
Mojtaba	Ajami	Islamic Azad University of zanjan
Ahmad	Akbari	Iran University of Science and Technology
Behzad	Akbari	Tarbiat Modares University
mohammad	Akbari	ICT Research Institute
Mohammad	Akhaee	University of Tehran
Sadegh	Aliakbari	Shahid Beheshti University
Hadi	Aliakbarian	K. N. Toosi University of Technology
Ghasem	Alipoor	Hamedan University of Technology‎
Hamidreza	Amindavar	Amirkabir University of Technology
Morteza	Analoui	Iran University of Science and Technology
Abouzar	Arabsorkhi	ICT Research Institute
Ehsan	Arianyan	ICT Research Institute
Farid	Ashtiani	Sharif University
Reza	Atani	University of Guilan
Mohammad	Azadnia	ICT Research Institute
Paeiz	Azmi	Tarbiat Modarres University
Kambiz	Badie	ICT Research Institute
Alireza	Bagheri	Amirkabir University of Technology
Gholamreza	Baghersalimi	University of Guilan
Fariba	Bahrami	Tehran University
Marjan	Bahrololum	ICT Research Institute
Hamidreza	Bakhshi	Shahed University
Bahador	Bakhshi saraskanrood	Amirkabir University of Technology
Nik mohammad	Balouchzahi	University of Sistan and Baluchestan
Morteza	Barari	Malek-Ashtar University of Technology
Ali	Bastami	K. N. Toosi University of Technology
Aliasghar	Beheshtishirazi	Iran University of Science and Technology
Hamid	Beigy	Sharif University of Technology
Lotfollah	Beigy	K. N. Toosi University of Technology
Reza	Berangi	Iran University of Science and Technology
Hamzeh	Beyranvand	Amirkabir University of Technology
Ali	Bohlooli	University of Isfahan
mohammadHadi	Bokaei	ICT Research Institute
Reza	Boostani	Shiraz University
Hossein	Boubarshad	Tehran University
Mohammad	Dakhilalian	Sanati Isfahan
Yousef	Darmani	K. N. Toosi University of Technology
Parisa	Dehkhoda	Amirkabir University of Technology
Vali	Derhami	Electrical and Computer Eng. Dept of Yazd University
Mohsen	Ebrahimi moghaddam	Shahid Beheshti University
Amirmasoud	Eftekhari	Qazvin Azad University
Mohammad	Ehdaie	Sharif University
Mohammad javad	Emadi	Amirkabir University of Technology
Mohammad Mehdi	Esnaashari	K. N. Toosi University of Technology
Heshaam	Faili	University of Tehran
Abolfazl	Falahati	Iran University of Science and Technology
Shahrokh	Farahmand	Iran University of Science and Technology
Reza	Faraji-Dana	University of Tehran
Mojgan	Farhoodi	ICT Research Institute
Forouhar	Farzaneh	Sharif University of Technology
Mehdi	Fasanghari	ICT Research Institute
Omid	Fatemi	University of Tehran
Emad	Fatemizadeh	Sharif University
Davood	Fathi	Tarbiat Modares University
Faranak	Fotouhi	Assistant Professor in Pervasive Computing
Akbar	Ghaffarpour rahbar	Sahand University of Technology
Hossein	Gharaee Garakani	ICT Research Institute
Davood	Gharavian	Shahid Beheshti University
Zahra	Ghattan kashani	K. N. Toosi University of Technology
Abolfazl	Ghavidel	Ferdowsi University of Mashhad
Mostafa	Ghazizadeh	Kerman University
Ahmadreza	Ghaznavi	Yazd University
Ali	Ghorayshi	Shahid Beheshti University
Pejman	Goudarzi	ICT Research Institute
Jafar	Habibi	Sharif University of Technology
Hamid	Haj seyyed javadi	Shahed University
Saman	Haratizadeh	Tehran University
Sattar	Hashemi	Shiraz University
Massoud Reza	Hashemi	Isfehan University of Technology
Shaahin	Hessabi	Sharif University of Technology
Mohammadmahdi	Homayounpoor	Amirkabir University of Technology University
Sasan	Hosseinalizadeh	ICT Research Institute
Seyed mehdi	Hosseini andargoli	Industry Univesity of Babool
Babak	Hosseinkhalaj	Sharif University of Technology
Maryam	Hourali	Malek Ashtar University of Technology
Ali	Jalili	Shahid Beheshti University
Rasool	Jalili	Sharif University of Technology
Saeed	Jalili	Tarbiat Modares University
Shahrokh	Jam	Shiraz University of Technology
Mahdi	Jampour	Quchan University of Technology
Hoda	Jannati	Institute for Research in Fundamental Sciences (IPM)
Roghayeh	Joda	ICT Research Institute
Jahanshah	Kabudian	Razi University
Mohammadhossein	Kahaei	Iran University of Science and Technology
Mohsen	Kahani	Ferdowsi University of Mashhad
Mahmod	Kamarei	University of Tehran
Mohammadreza	Kangavari	Iran University of Science and Technology
Mohammadazim	Karami	Iran University of Science and Technology
Ahmad	Kardan	Amirkabir University of Technology
Mehdi	Kargahi	University of Tehran
Mohammad javad	Kargar	University of Science and Culture
Mohammad Bagher	Karimi	Iran Polymer and Petrochemical Institute
Shohreh	Kasaei	Sharif University of Technology
Manoochehr	Kelarestaghi	Kharazmi University
Marjan	Keramati	Faculty Member of Semnan University
Alireza	Keshavarz haddad	Shiraz University
Ali asghar	Keshtkar	Qazvin International Imam Khomeini University
Amir Hosein	Keyhanipour	Tehran University
Mohammad reza	Keyvanpour	Department of Computer engineering
Ahmad	Khademzadeh	ICT Research Institute
Pejman	Khadivi	Isfahan University of Technology
Mohamad	Khansari	University of Tehran
Mahmood	Kharrat	ICT Research Institute
shahram	khazaei	Sharif University
Siyavash	Khorsandi	Amirkabir University of Technology University
Ramtin	Khosravi	University of Tehran
Farshad	khunjush	Shiraz University
ali mohammd	latif	Islamic Azad University, Yazd Branch
keyvan	maghooli	Science and Research Branch, Islamic Azad University
Behrouz	Maham	University of Tehran
Nezamodin	Mahdavi Amiri	Sharif University
Mahdi	Majidi	Kashan University
Ehsan	Malekian	Kharazmi University
Mina	Malekzadeh	Hakim Sabzevari University
Alireza	Mallahzadeh	Shahed University
mohammad	manthouri	Shahed University
Naser	Masoumi	University of Tehran
Behrooz	masoumi	Islamic Azad University of QAZVIN
Mojtaba	Mazoochi	ICT Research Institute
Mehri	Mehrjoo	University of Sistan & Baluchestan
Mohammadreza	Meybodi	Amirkabir University of Technology University
Behrouz	Minaei	Iran University of Science and Technology
Mir mojtaba	Mirsalehi	Ferdowsi University of Mashhad
Mohamad	Mirsaraf	Research Institute for ICT
Masoud	Mirrezaei	Shahrood University of Technology
Mohsen	Mivehchi	University of isfahan
farrokhLagha	moazemi	Shahid Beheshti University
Ali	Moeini	University of Tehran
Amir hossein	Mohajer zadeh	Ferdowsi University of Mashhad
Sudabeh	Mohamadi	Kermanshah University of Technology
ayoub	mohamadian	Tehran University
Abbas	Mohammadi	Amirkabir University of Technology University
Karim	Mohammadpour aghdam	University of Tehran
Hoda	Mohammadzade	ه Sharif University
Naser	Mohammadzadeh	Shahed University
Mohammad-Shahram	Moin	ICT Research Institute
Nader	Mokari	Tarbiat Modares University
Gholamali	Montazer	Tarbiat Modares University
Ahmad Reza	Montazerolghaem	Quchan University of Technology
Gholamreza	Moradi	Amirkabir University of Technology University
Mohammadhasan	Moradi	Amirkabir University of Technology University
Behzad Moshiri	Moshiri	Tehran University
Ali	Movagharrahimabadi	Sharif University of Technology
Zeinab	Movahedi	Iran University of Science and Technology
Naser	Mozayani	Iran University of Science and Technology
Abdolreza	Nabavi	Tarbiat Modares University
Manoochehr	Nahvi	University of Guilan
Babak	Najjararaabi	University of Tehran
Mansour	Nakhkesh	Yazd University
Mohammad Naser-Moghadasi	Naser-Moghadasi	Science and Research Branch, Islamic Azad University
Masoomeh	Nasirikenari	Sharif University of Technology
Keyvan	Navi	Shahid Beheshti University
Behzad	Nazari	Isfahan University of Technology
Eslam	Nazemi	Shahid Beheshti University
Mohammad	Neshat	Tehran University
Mahmood	Neshati	Shahid Beheshti University
Majid	Niliahmadabadi	University of Tehran
Yaser	Norouzi	Amirkabir University of Technology University
Majid	Nourhosseini	Amirkabir University of Technology
Ali	Olfat	University of Tehran
Mohammad Saleh	owlia	Yazd University
Mohammadreza	Pakravan	Sharif University of Technology
ُaeede	Parsaseefard	Amirkabir University of Technology University
Mirmohsen	Pedram	Kharazmi University
Mohammad	Pooyan	Shahed University
Vahid	Pourahmad	Amirkabir University of Technology
Mohammad Ali	Pourmina	Islamic Azad University, Science and Research Branch
Amirmasoud	Rabiee	University of Tehran
Adel	Rahmani	Iran University of Science and Technology
Amir Masoud	Rahmani	Science And Research
Rouholah	Rahmani	Tehran University
Mohammad	Rahmati	Amirkabir University of Technology University
Jalil	Rashedmohassel	University of Tehran
Mehdi	Rasti	Amirkabir University of Technology University
Nasser	Razavi	University of Tabriz
Mohammad	Razavizadeh	Iran University of Science and Technology
Mohammad Reza	Rezaei	Universidad Complutense de Madrid,
Alireza	Rezvanian	Amirkabir University of Technology
Reza	Saadat	Yazd University
babak	Sadeghian	Amirkabir University of Technology University
Hadi	Sadjadi	ICT Research Institute
Seyed mohammadsajad	Sadough	Shahid Beheshti University
Fatemeh	Saghafi	University of Tehran
Tahereh	Saheb	Tarbiat Modares University
Hossein	Saidi	Isfahan University of Technology
Mehdi	Salaynaderi	Amirkabir University of Technology University
Mahmood	Salmasizadeh	Sharif University of Technology
Hosein	Sameti	Sharif University of Technology
Mehdi	Samie	ICT Research Institute
Hossein	Samimi	ICT Research Institute
Mohammad	Sayad haghighi	Tehran University
Mohammad ali	Sebt	K. N. Toosi University of Technology
Sanaz	Seyedin	Amirkabir University of Technology
Babak	Seyfe	Shahed University
Seyyed Ali	Seyyedsalehi	Amirkabir University of Technology
Mahmood	Shahabadi	University of Tehran
Behrouz	Shahgholi	University of Isfahan
Hamidreza	shahriari	ICT Research Institute
Azadeh	Shakery	University of Tehran
alireza	shameli	Shahid Beheshti University
Fereidoon	Shams	Shahid Beheshti University
Mehrnoosh	Shamsfard	Shahid Beheshti University
Mohsen	Sharifi	Iran University of Science and Technology
Arash	Sharifi	Science and Research Branch, Islamic Azad University
Mohammad Javad	Shayegan Fard	University of science and culture
Mohammad hossein	Sheikhi	Shiraz University
Solmaz	Sheisari	Islamic Azad University Pardis branch,
Mohammad ebrahim	Shiri ahamdabadi	Amirkabir University of Technology University
saeed	shiry gheidari	Amirkabir University of Technology University
Omid	Shoaei	University of Tehran
Mehran	Soleimanfallah	Amirkabir University of Technology University
Hadi	Soleimany	Shahid Beheshti University
Mohammad reza	Taban	Yazd University
Mohammadhessam	Tadayon	ICT Research Institute
Aliakbar	Tadayon taft	Yazd University
Tala	Tafazzoli	ICT Research Institute
Hasan	Taheri	Amirkabir University of Technology University
Mahmoud Mohammad	Taheri	University of Tehran
Majid	Tayarani	Iran University of Science and Technology
Maryam	Tayefehmahmoudi	ICT Research Institute
Mohammad	Teshnehlab	K. N. Toosi University of Technology
Mohammad ali	Tinati	Tabriz University
Sara	Tofighi	ICT Research Institute
Elaheh	Vaezpour	ICT Research Institute
mansour	vali	K. N. Toosi University of Technology
Marziyeh	Varposhti	Islamic Azad University
Hadi	Veisi	Tehran University
Mohammad Hossein	Yaghmae	Ferdowsi University of Mashhad
Farzin	Yaghmaei	Semnan University
Ali Reza	Yamghani	Islamic Azad University of Lahijan
alireza	Yari	ICT Research Institute
Hassan	Yeganeh	Iran Telecommunication Research Center
leyla	yousefi	Tehran University
Mohammad Hadi	Zahedi	K. N. Toosi University of Technology
Hosein	Zamirijafarian	Mashhad University
Esa	Zarepour	Iran University of Science and Technology
Farzad	Zargariasl	ICT Research Institute
Hooman	Zarrabi	ICT Research Institute